Choosing the perfect food for your coral is absolutely crucial. This will help them to reproduce faster and glow more. The two most preferred coral foods out there currently are Reef-Roids and Coral Frenzy.
And you must have stumbled while choosing food for your corals. So, if we compare coral frenzy vs reef roids, which will prevail?
Coral Frenzy is expensive than Reef-Roids, but it offers better value for money. The reason is the difference in dosage rate of these two. As a result, you need less amount of Coral Frenzy compared to Reef-Roids. Also, the versatility of Coral Frenzy gives it an edge over Reef-Roids.
Here, we have tried to make your life simpler by comparing them thoroughly. You’ll get everything you need to know about these two coral foods in this article. Let’s start!
Coral Frenzy vs Reef Roids: Brief Comparison
Corals normally get their nutrition from natural sources like fish waste in reef tanks. They also consume zooplankton, and other floating tiny animals. However, to make them flourish you need to supply them with additional nutrients.
We have tried out both Coral Frenzy and Reef-Roids in our reef tanks. We noticed that different types of corals have different reactions to these two foods.
So, which one to pick from reef roids vs coral frenzy? It can be difficult as they are very similar. When you compare coralife biocube vs oceanic biocube you face the same problem.
Here are two basic variants of these two coral foods with a brief summary.
Coral Frenzy vs Reef Roids: Head-to-Head Discussion
Coral Frenzy and Reef Roids are two very easy-to-use coral foods. You may want to supply live food in your reef tank. But you lack either time or discipline to do that. This can be a great alternative to live food.
Well, to make things easier for you here we’ve compared them briefly in various categories.
| Category | Coral Frenzy | Reef Roids |
| Cost | 18-60 $ | 14-37 $ |
| Type | Pellets or Powder | Powder-ish |
| Package Size | 45, 90, 180 grams | 30, 60, 120 grams |
| Dosage Rate | 1/2 teaspoon per 100 gallons | 1 teaspoon per 100 gallons |
| Shelf Life | 12 months | 12 months |
| Availability | Less | More |
| Preferred Coral Types | Mostly LPS | Mostly SPS |
| Feeding System | Broadcast Feeding or Target Feeding | Target Feeding |
| Where to Buy | Buy Now from Amazon | Buy Now from Amazon |
Nevertheless, they both have their advantages and disadvantages over one another. So, let’s dive right in and try to find out the best coral food for your own tank.
Cost
The main purpose of coral food is to nourish corals. Coral Frenzy and Reef-Roids both serve this purpose properly. Nonetheless, there are some dissimilarities between them.
Coral Frenzy is a bit more expensive than Reef Roids if you consider the packaging amount. You can get various amounts of powdered Coral Frenzy ranging from 18 to 60 bucks. They can be bought as 45gm, 90gm, 180gm packages. Here are some-
| Product Name | Quantity | Check Price |
| Coral Frenzy Powder Formula with Probiotics | 45 grams | Check Price |
| Coral Frenzy Powder Formula with Probiotics | 90 grams | Check Price |
| Coral Frenzy Powder Formula with Probiotics | 180 grams | Check Price |
In contrast, reef roids will give you more content at a lower rate. You can buy Reef-Roids ranging from 14 to 37 dollars on amazon. The package size ranges from 30gm to 120gm.
Here are some Reef-Roids according to their quantity-
| Product Name | Quantity | Check Price |
| Nano Reef-Roids | 30 grams | Check Price |
| Reef-Roids | 60 grams | Check Price |
| Professional Reef-Roids | 120 grams | Check Price |
Verdict: Reef-Roids is the undisputed winner in this category. Because the package provides more content at a certain amount of money.
Components
It’s important to know what you are actually feeding your corals. Normally, the ingredients are written on the label of the package.
However, we’ve made a comparison between these two based on the ingredients they contain. This will give you a better idea about the products.
| Ingredients | Coral Frenzy | Reef-Roids |
| Crude Protein (min) | 53.7% | 60% |
| Crude Lipid (min) | 18% | 20% |
| Crude Fiber (max) | 2.87% | 8% |
| Ash (max) | 11.8% | 6% |
| Moisture (max) | 6.26% | 6% |
| Astaxanthin | 80-100 ppm | 150-200 ppm |
These are the basic ingredients and the respective amounts these products contain. Additionally, Coral Frenzy contains a minimum amount of 1,000,000 cfu/g probiotic blends.
Probiotic blends help the coral to digest these foods easily. As a result, their growth increases rapidly.
Verdict: As you can see, the amount of different components are quite similar. However, the addition of probiotic blend gives Coral Frenzy an edge over Reef-Roids.
Dosage Rate
Another big dissimilarity between these two is the dosage rate. In both cases, you need to use them 2-3 times per week. However, the amount of food needed for certain volumes of the tank is different.
The instruction on the bottle suggests mixing 1 tsp of Reef-Roids per 100 gallons. In contrast, you only need 1/2 tablespoon of Coral Frenzy for 100 gallons. You can clearly see, the required amount of Coral Frenzy is half of that of Reef-Roids.
Verdict: The amount of Coral Frenzy needed is less than Reef-Roids. That’s why it will last longer than Reef-Roids.
Efficiency
Reef Roids is hailed as one of the best coral food to grow your corals. Furthermore, Reef Roids are cheaper than Coral Frenzy as well.
However, you should consider the dosage rate to calculate the actual cost of this product. As we know, you need less amount of Coral Frenzy than Reef-Roids. So, which one will last longer? No worries! Let us explain it here.
1/2 tsp means 2.84 grams and 1 tsp equals 5.69 grams. Many hobbyists suggest using coral food twice or thrice a week. Here’s a table explaining the usage of the two coral foods that are in the discussion here.
| Time | Quantity needed for Reef-Roids | Quantity needed for Coral Frenzy |
| Weekly | 17.07 gm/0.6021 oz | 8.52 gm/ 0.3 oz |
| Monthly | 68.28 gm/ 2.4 oz | 34.08 gm/ 1.2 oz |
| Yearly | 3618.84 gm/ 127.65 oz | 1806.24 gm/ 63.71 |
As you can see you’ll need a larger quantity of Reef Roids per year than Coral Frenzy.
Verdict: Even though the base price of Reef Roids is lower than Coral Frenzy, Coral Frenzy will last long. And as a result, Coral Frenzy is more efficient as you need to spend less.
Shelf Life
The shelf life of coral food is important. It gives us an idea of how long it’ll act as expected and stay usable. A product will exhibit exact perceived characteristics inside the shelf life.
Now, the label of Coral Frenzy and Reef Roids shows the same shelf life. 12 months is the reef roids shelf life or this is what they claim. Coral Frenzy also claims that the shelf life of their product is 12 months.
Food Type
Choosing the proper food type is a must in coral feeding. If you use the wrong one, it might ruin everything you’ve worked for. The balance of your tank will be jeopardized.
The corals in your tank will not consume the wrong type of food. As a result, the food will go to waste and compile at the bottom of the tank. With time they will degrade and pollute the tank water.
So, how can you select the suitable food type for your tank?
Well, first you need to know what kind of coral you have inside your tank. Because different types of corals consume different types of food. Some react very well to liquid food and others to pellets.
If you are targeting a coral colony, pellets will provide condensed nutrients. But this can only be done with LPS (Large Polyp Stony) corals.
Unlike LPS corals, SPS corals have a thin layer covering their skeleton. This skin does not inflate and is made up of numerous small polyps. These polyps each has one mouth on them. As a result, Small Polyp Stony can’t consume bigger-sized pellets with their smaller mouth.
Liquid food is free from this constraint. The SPS corals love it when they get their food in liquid form. That’s why liquid food is considered SPS coral food. But the problem occurs when it comes to LPS corals.
Liquid food will dilute very quickly in the water column. In turn, the LPS corals will find it difficult to gather their essential nutrients.
Therefore, if you have an LPS-dominant aquarium, pellets will give your better result. But if you have a mixed coral reef then liquid food is the way to go.
Coral Frenzy has both powder-ish and pellet variants of products. You can easily choose any of them according to your tank’s requirements.
| Product Name | Food Type | Check Price |
| Coral Frenzy 0.5 mm Reef & Fish Pellet | Pellets | Check Price |
| Coral Frenzy The ULTIMATE Coral Food | Powder | Check Price |
This versatility in choosing a different type of food is unavailable with Reef-Roids. Thus, making Coral Frenzy more desirable between these two.
Suitability
It’s not possible to have one solution to all the problems in a reef tank. The same goes for coral foods. The two coral foods have their own expertise on different types of corals.
Coral Frenzy
The coral frenzy pellets are great for LPS corals. They almost deform when food pellets are sprinkled on top of them. This sight of corals eating their food will even make you happy.
However, SPS corals can also enjoy coral frenzy, but in powder form.
Reef-Roids
Reef-Roids is one of the best foods there is for SPS corals. Not only the SPS corals but also some invertebrates consume this food. You can see polyp extensions instantly when the food is being supplied to corals.
It contains a unique species of zooplankton that corals eat. Filter-feedings corals are very fond of this food. Especially Zoanthids, Goniopora and some mushrooms.
Feeding Method
There are two types of feeding systems specific for coral food. One of them is broadcast feeding and another one is target feeding. Both of these feeding types serve different purposes and have their own pros and cons.
Broadcast feeding provides the coral food for everything inside the tank. The food distributed through broadcast feeding dissolves into the water. Thus making the food available to all the organisms inside the tank.
On the contrary, targeted food is given to the corals through a pipette or syringe. In this process, the food falls directly on the corals. As a result, the corals can directly consume the food as per their need.
We have tried out syringes and pipettes while feeding corals. Here are some of the best according to our on-hand experience.
| Image | Product | Unique Feature 1 | Unique Feature 2 | Unique Feature 3 | Buy Now |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
  | ANDGOO Coral Feeder | Both SPS and LPS feeder | Acrylic made long syringe | High Quality, multi-functional and safe for fish | Buy Now |
  | PeSandy Coral Feeder | Easily operable | Made of sturdy material with rubber at the top | Long enough to keep your hand dry | Buy Now |
  | Aquarium Choice Coral Feeder | Rubber suction nozzle | Various way of use | 25 ml liquid container | Buy Now |
If you compare these two methods, the broadcasting method is easier. But it has a risk of overfeeding the tank and raising nitrate levels. However, the targeting method needs much more effort compared to the broadcasting one.
Now, after much experimenting, we saw corals react better when they’re target-fed.
If you prefer the coral frenzy pellets, you must apply target feeding. But make sure not to add an excessive amount of it. Otherwise, it’ll accumulate at the bottom of the tank and ruin the water.
You can either broadcast or target feed the powdered food. However, to maintain balance inside the tank, it’s better to target feed. Because it’ll reduce the amount of wastage of food.
Another great tip is to not apply the mixture directly to the corals. You should apply them just a bit in front of them. The powerhead in your tank will carry the food to the corals.
However, if your existing fluval spec v isn’t performing up to the expectation try to upgrade it.
Moreover, there are many types of powerheads in the market. It can be confusing to choose one. To make things easy, we have curated some of the powerheads that we’ve used before.
| Product | GPH Rating | Check Price |
| SunSun JVP Series | 530 to 800 GPH | Check Price |
| Uniclif Controllable Wavemaker | 1058 to 3400 GPH | Check Price |
| Jebao Cross Flow CP | 2700 to 3300 GPH | Check Price |
You can choose any of these pumps according to your budget and requirements.
Particle Size
Particle size is an important factor while considering coral food. It directly contributes to the versatility of coral food. Having a bigger range of particle size will result in more corals consuming it.
Different corals have different preferences. And that’s why it’s better to supply foods that have a bigger particle size range.
The particle size of Coral Frenzy is 53 to 1700 microns. In comparison, Reef-Roids have a much lower range at around 150 to 200 microns.
Verdict: Coral Frenzy gives a bigger range thus making it more desirable in this category.
Water Degradation
Anything non-natural is a problem in a closed system. Additional nutrients are no exception. Nevertheless, using the right amount of additional nutrients will not do any harm.
There’s a saying, too much of anything is bad for everything. The same goes for additional nutrients. Excessive amounts of nutrients might cause an algae outbreak.
Coral Frenzy and Reef-Roids do not degrade water when used in a limit. However, the foods that go uneaten by the corals will ruin the balance of the tank. As a result, you might notice problems like coral stopped opening up.
As we know, target feeding reduces the amount of wastage of food. So, we recommend trying this feeding method to prevent degradation of the water.
Effects on Other Organisms Inside the Tank
The other organisms usually give a positive reaction to any type of food. If you use a quality product the whole environment in the tank becomes exciting.
The same thing happens when you use these two products in the discussion. Reef-Roids, when put in, even the fishes in the tank become happy. The excitement inside the tank is a thing to watch when Reef-Roids are added.
Coral Frenzy also lifts up the mood inside the reef tank. Some of the invertebrates eat it as well.
Which One Should You Choose?
It is really tough to choose a winner between these two coral foods. Both of them will nourish your coral reefs greatly. The nutrients that they contain are also very similar. Even the amount of the components is also almost identical.
There are some dissimilarities between them as well. One of them is the cost, Reef-Roids are much cheaper than Coral Frenzy. However, if you think about value for money Coral Frenzy is a much better choice.
You will need almost double the amount of Reef-Roids than Coral Frenzy. And as we have calculated the cost becomes much higher when you consider a long time.
Also, the particle size of Coral Frenzy is much more versatile than Reef-Roids. You can also get either pellets or powder coral food if you choose Coral Frenzy.
You should always choose coral food according to your corals. The pellets will be a better option for LPS corals. Powder one will help the SPS corals to grow more swiftly.
Therefore, considering cost and versatility Coral Frenzy is the superior one. However, there are many aquarists who found better results while using Reef-Roids.
We are comparing two of the best coral foods in the market. You can easily choose one and start feeding your corals as suggested. You will not regret a bit of it and your corals will love it.
FAQs
Can you feed hammer coral Reef-Roids?
Hammer corals do not need to be fed most of the time. Because they eat on fish waste and photosynthesis. Nevertheless, they do benefit from additional feeding. So, you can feed hammer coral Reef-Roids.
Does anemone eat pellets?
Pellets provide anemones with a balanced diet. In the reef habitat, these pellets mimic the bigger pieces of food or entire fish. They often simply dismantle these pellets with their tentacles for tiny anemones.
How often should my Zoanthids be fed?
Zoanthids prefer consuming meaty foods. It helps them to reproduce faster. Thus, feeding it frequently should be the goal. However, frequently doesn’t mean every day. You should feed them twice or thrice a week.
Bottomline
Feeding your corals with additional food is a great way to keep them nourished and happy. It is also directly involved with the tank’s environment. So, choosing the best coral food is the key to keeping balance in your tank.
We tried to present everything we could on coral frenzy vs reef roids. Hope we could help you guys out with your dilemma.
If it’s still not clear enough, do let us know in the comments. Thanks for staying with us!